A useful Liu Yao case record lets another reader reconstruct the cast, see why a line was selected, and distinguish what was concluded before an outcome from what was added later. Use this template to document the question, time and casting method, chart, reasoning, and observable result. It is designed for study and review—not to prove that a reading predicts events.
Why a case record needs more than a hexagram name
Writing down only a hexagram name or a short verdict removes the information needed to evaluate the reading. A reviewer cannot tell whether the question was narrow, whether the six lines were entered in the right order, which calendar settings were used, or what evidence supported the chosen Key Significator. A complete record also makes misses visible. Keeping only memorable successes creates a distorted picture of a method.
Liu Yao is a six-line divination method associated with the Yijing tradition, but it is not interchangeable with reading a hexagram text alone. A Liu Yao case commonly records line positions, branch and phase assignments, Six Relations, Self and Response, changing lines, and time factors. Readers and schools may differ in rules and emphasis. Write down the method actually used rather than presenting one convention as universal.
1. Define the question and its real-world context
- Case ID: assign a unique reference. Original question: preserve the exact wording, including the subject, action, time window, and an observable result. Querent’s role: state whether the question concerns the querent, an authorized team representative, or another person, and record the basis for consent. Known facts: list only relevant events or constraints already known when the cast was made. Decision status: note whether the action is still open, already submitted, or awaiting a response. Outcome test: define in advance what will count as complete, incomplete, or unknown. Privacy: remove names, addresses, account details, and identifying information about third parties.
A question such as “Will things work out?” is difficult to review because neither the subject nor success is defined. A more useful form identifies one situation and a deadline, for example: “Will I receive a written response to this application by the stated date?” The wording should match a real decision or observation, not invite a claim about another person’s private thoughts.
2. Preserve the time and casting method
- Record the civil date and time, location, and time zone used for the cast. State which calendar or almanac settings determined the month branch, day pillar, cycle, and void branches. Name the casting method: yarrow stalks, three coins, or a specific digital tool and version. For coins, write the value assigned to each face and the rule that converts three values into a line. Record all six raw results from the first line at the bottom to the sixth line at the top, using the method’s stated values. Note whether this was the first cast on this question
- if another cast was made, preserve its time, result, and reason rather than discarding it.
Do not infer missing birth, calendar, or casting details from the chart you hope to obtain. If a date, time zone, or raw line value is unknown, mark it unknown. The record should show what the reader actually had available, not a cleaner version reconstructed after the event.
3. Record the chart so it can be reconstructed
- Write the primary hexagram name and its six yin or yang lines. List each moving line and show how it changes
- then record the resulting hexagram and its six lines. Include the hexagram palace and phase assignments if the chosen method uses them. For every line, preserve the branch, phase, Six Relation, and any hidden or flying signifier included in the analysis. Identify Self and Response positions and state the convention used. Save a text export or a dated image when useful, but do not make an image the only record of essential line data.
If manual calculations and a software chart disagree, pause interpretation until the discrepancy is resolved or clearly documented. A changed line, line order, or calendar setting can alter the chart being discussed. A confident explanation built on an uncertain cast is not a substitute for checking the input.
4. Show the reasoning chain, not just the verdict
- Primary Key Significator: name the line chosen for the question and explain why its Six Relation and context fit the subject. Secondary factors: identify any supporting lines and explain their limited role. Self and Response: state what each position represents in this question without treating them as substitutes for the Key Significator. Time conditions: record how the relevant line relates to the month branch, day pillar, cycle, and void under the declared method. Changes and interactions: describe the moving line, resulting position, generation, control, clash, or combination only where the rule applies. Evidence balance: list supporting signals, constraints, alternative readings, and important unknowns separately. Initial conclusion: preserve the wording and confidence limits written before the outcome. Review date: set when the result will be checked.
A helpful explanation connects each interpretive step to a stated rule. For example, if the question concerns a written notice, the reader might explain why a Parent Relation line is relevant in that context. The label alone is not evidence that a notice will arrive. The line’s condition, interactions, question scope, and practical circumstances still matter, and different line choices may lead to different readings.
A worked example of the record, not a prediction
Suppose a querent asks, “I submitted the course materials; will I receive a written admission notice by June 30?” A three-coin cast is recorded with the face values, the six results from bottom to top, the cast date, location, time zone, and calendar settings. The sample values are 8, 7, 8, 9, 7, 8, which produce the primary hexagram Lake over Water, one moving fourth line, and the resulting hexagram Water over Water under this casting convention.
That chart description is only the structural record. It does not justify a conclusion such as “the first hexagram means restriction, so the answer is no.” The case still needs the relevant date and time factors, line assignments, Six Relations, Self and Response positions, and a stated reason for selecting the line that represents the written notice. The reader must then explain what the moving line contributes, what evidence points the other way, and whether any calendar or school assumptions remain unsettled. If those inputs are absent, record that the interpretation is incomplete rather than inventing them.
5. Append the result without editing the original reading
When the review date arrives, add a dated outcome note using the test defined before the cast. Record the observable fact and its source—for example, whether a written notice was received by the deadline. Keep the original question and initial conclusion unchanged. If the result is delayed, ambiguous, or not independently verifiable, label it that way instead of forcing it into a yes-or-no category.
Then compare the result with the original claim. Which parts matched the prewritten test? Which did not? Did the question leave room to reinterpret the answer? Did new information arise after the cast? A review can expose a calculation error, an unclear question, or a weak inference. It need not end with a claim that the method succeeded or failed in every respect.
Common record-keeping errors
- Saving the hexagram name but not the six original line values. Recording lines from top to bottom without declaring that convention. Confusing the date of the outcome with the date of the cast. Recasting until a preferred answer appears and preserving only that chart. Replacing the original conclusion after an event. Treating a Six Relation label as proof of a specific person or event. Reporting a precise time when the source data are approximate. Publishing private information or a third party’s identifying details. Calling a reading accurate without defining an observable test.
A compact reusable case form
- Case ID and review date: [record]. Original question and time window: [quote exactly]. Querent role and consent: [record]. Known facts and decision status: [record]. Cast date, local time, place, and time zone: [record]. Calendar and boundary settings: [record]. Casting method and raw lines, bottom to top: [record]. Primary and resulting hexagrams
- moving lines: [record]. Palace, branches, phases, Six Relations, Self and Response: [record under declared method]. Key Significator and reason: [record]. Time factors and interactions: [record]. Supporting evidence, limits, alternatives, and unknowns: [record]. Initial conclusion and confidence limits: [freeze before outcome]. Dated result, observable evidence, and source: [append later]. Review: [what matched, missed, or remained unclear].
Further study and responsible limits
For a broader introduction to the sequence from a clear question through a six-line reading, see Liu Yao for Beginners. For related method details, compare Liu Yao Six Relations, Self and Response Lines in Liu Yao, and Liu Yao Timing Factors. Those guides address distinct parts of the reasoning process; this template focuses on preserving a case so its inputs and later review remain visible.
Classical works such as Zengshan Bu Yi, Bu Shi Zheng Zong, Yi Yin, and Huang Jin Ce can be consulted for historical case formats and interpretive approaches. Editions and commentaries may differ, and older examples often omit modern details such as time-zone settings, privacy practices, or explicit outcome tests. Use them as material for comparison, not as guarantees or substitutes for documenting your own method.
This template supports historical and reflective study. It does not replace qualified medical, legal, or financial advice, and a reading should not be presented as a guaranteed result. When a situation involves an urgent health concern, a legal deadline, or material financial risk, use appropriate professional services and evidence-based procedures.